Peter, Paul, and Mary, one of the most iconic folk trios of the 1960s, are celebrated for their ability to weave storytelling into heartfelt musical arrangements. Their song “Stewball,” from the album Peter, Paul and Mary In Concert (1964), is a masterful rendition of a centuries-old ballad. With its gentle harmonies, evocative instrumentation, and poignant narrative, “Stewball” is a fine example of their craft. This review will delve into the song’s historical context, explore the unique instrumental arrangement, and suggest similar songs for further exploration.
The Album: Peter, Paul and Mary In Concert
Peter, Paul and Mary In Concert was released in 1964, showcasing the trio’s charisma and dynamic stage presence. The album captures the essence of live folk music, where storytelling and audience engagement play vital roles. It features a mix of traditional ballads, contemporary folk songs, and original compositions. Songs like “Blowin’ in the Wind” and “Puff, the Magic Dragon” made the trio household names, but it’s lesser-celebrated tracks like “Stewball” that highlight their deep connection to folk traditions.
The live setting of the album adds a layer of authenticity to “Stewball.” The audience’s occasional murmurs and applause make it feel intimate and raw, underscoring the song’s emotional depth. This piece of music embodies the ethos of folk: storytelling, simplicity, and heartfelt expression.
The Story of “Stewball”
“Stewball” is a narrative ballad with roots in the 18th century, telling the story of a racehorse named Stewball, whose triumphs and tragedies capture the imagination of the listeners. This tale of an underdog horse, who was both loved and lost, resonates with themes of hope, loss, and the passage of time. While versions of “Stewball” exist in both English and American traditions, Peter, Paul, and Mary’s interpretation feels deeply personal, as if they are recounting the story to a circle of friends.
Their version is stripped down yet emotionally charged. The trio’s harmonies elevate the storytelling, drawing the listener into the poignant narrative. Peter Yarrow’s and Paul Stookey’s voices, combined with Mary Travers’ warm alto, create a vocal blend that is both soothing and haunting.
Instrumentation and Sounds
The instrumental arrangement in “Stewball” is deceptively simple but remarkably effective. The song relies heavily on acoustic guitar, a hallmark of Peter, Paul, and Mary’s style. The guitar provides a soft, rhythmic strumming pattern that sets the pace for the song, allowing the vocals to take center stage. The restrained use of guitar in this piece of music reflects the ethos of folk music—minimalist, yet profound.
Additionally, subtle piano chords add a layer of depth to the arrangement, weaving seamlessly with the guitar’s steady rhythm. This interplay between guitar and piano is a hallmark of the trio’s ability to blend instruments in service of the song’s narrative. The simplicity of the instrumentation enhances the raw emotion of the lyrics, ensuring that the focus remains on the storytelling.
The vocal harmonies are the crown jewel of the song. Peter, Paul, and Mary’s ability to harmonize with precision and feeling gives “Stewball” its timeless quality. Each voice serves its role—whether carrying the melody or adding texture with well-placed harmonics. Their vocal synergy is unparalleled, and it’s what makes “Stewball” a standout track on the album.
The Song’s Emotional Impact
“Stewball” is a song that lingers with the listener. Its melancholic tone invites introspection, and its narrative sparks empathy. The story of Stewball the racehorse, with all its bittersweet twists, mirrors the universal human experience of love, loss, and fleeting moments of triumph.
The live recording of the song enhances its emotional impact. You can almost sense the audience holding their breath as the trio delivers the song with heartfelt sincerity. The simplicity of the arrangement leaves no room for distraction, making the song feel both personal and profound.
Recommended Songs for Similar Listening
If you’ve fallen in love with “Stewball,” there are several other tracks that capture a similar emotional and musical essence. Here are a few recommendations:
- “The Last Thing on My Mind” by Tom Paxton
Another folk classic, this song captures the bittersweet feeling of parting and regret, with a similar emphasis on storytelling and acoustic arrangements. - “Wild Horses” by The Rolling Stones
While rooted in rock, this ballad has a gentle, acoustic feel and tells a poignant story, making it a fitting companion to “Stewball.” - “If I Had a Hammer” by Peter, Paul, and Mary
For those who appreciate the trio’s vocal harmonies, this upbeat yet meaningful song is a must-listen. - “The Long Black Veil” by Johnny Cash
A narrative-driven piece of music with haunting melodies, this song will resonate with fans of “Stewball.” - “Barbara Allen” by Joan Baez
This traditional folk ballad shares a similar historical and emotional depth, beautifully performed by one of the genre’s most iconic voices.
The Legacy of “Stewball”
“Stewball” remains a shining example of how music can bridge the past and the present. Peter, Paul, and Mary’s rendition honors the song’s folk roots while bringing their unique artistry to it. The combination of acoustic guitar, piano, and vocal harmonies transforms a simple ballad into a moving piece of music that continues to captivate audiences.
For those seeking music that speaks to the soul, “Stewball” is a reminder of the power of storytelling through song. Whether you are exploring the broader catalog of Peter, Paul, and Mary or venturing into the rich world of folk music, this track is a perfect starting point.
Conclusion
“Stewball” by Peter, Paul, and Mary is a testament to the enduring power of folk music. With its heartfelt storytelling, beautifully simple arrangement, and impeccable vocal harmonies, it’s a song that resonates deeply. The inclusion of guitar and piano as the foundation of the piece enhances its timeless appeal, making it an essential track for fans of the genre.
If you’re new to Peter, Paul, and Mary, or folk music in general, “Stewball” is an excellent introduction to their artistry. And for long-time fans, it’s a reminder of why this trio remains an integral part of the American folk tradition. Let “Stewball” lead you to explore other gems in the album and beyond—you won’t be disappointed.