The late 1970s were a time of sonic upheaval. Disco was peaking, punk was spitting, and the meticulously constructed machinery of teen-idol pop was starting to seize up. Into this charged atmosphere, the Bay City Rollers—a band whose fame was built on uncomplicated bubblegum and a distinctively Scottish tartan brand—made a sudden, jarring artistic declaration. They released the album It’s A Game in 1977, and the title track itself, “It’s A Game,” was the sound of a band desperately trying to grow up in public.
I first heard this piece of music on a cheap portable radio late one night, the kind that delivered every bass line as a dull thud and every string section as an echoing wash. Even through that low-fidelity filter, the ambition was undeniable. Gone were the handclaps and the chirpy, four-on-the-floor rhythms of “Saturday Night” or “Bye Bye Baby.” In their place was something grander, something that aspired to the kind of complex, mid-tempo drama being perfected by acts like Fleetwood Mac and ELO. It was a conscious attempt to shed the screaming crowds and the restrictive image, to be taken seriously as musicians, not just as a cultural phenomenon.
The track opens not with a driving power chord, but with a surprisingly delicate, almost cinematic arrangement. A stately piano figure establishes the central, slightly melancholic progression. It’s an arrangement that calls for a deeper listen, a commitment that their earlier, instantly gratifying hits never required. The production, reportedly helmed by studio veteran Harry Maslin—known for his work with David Bowie—suggests a meticulous, expensive approach. Every component is given space to breathe, a hallmark of the burgeoning AOR sound.
Listen closely to the texture. The rhythmic foundation is subtle yet propulsive. The drums employ complex fills and a measured beat that emphasizes the emotional weight of the verses. The bass line is not merely functional; it’s melodic, snaking beneath the surface, providing a sophisticated harmonic anchor. The core instrumentation is built around a classic rock setup—bass, drums, guitar, and keys—but layered with sweeping, gorgeous orchestral flourishes. These strings are not tacked on; they are integral to the song’s emotional architecture, swelling at key moments to give the song its sense of gravitas and drama. It’s here, in the interplay of the rhythm section with the studio strings, that the track transcends its origins.
The vocal delivery of Leslie McKeown is a crucial element of the transformation. He dials down the effervescent charm of the teen-pop era, adopting a world-weary, slightly husky tone. The subject matter itself—the acceptance of life’s emotional risks, the understanding that love and loss are simply parts of a larger design—reflects an attempt to reach an older demographic. This shift in lyrical focus was pivotal. It was a bid for longevity, a recognition that the Rollermania demographic was rapidly aging out.
The arrangement uses dynamic contrast expertly. The verses are relatively sparse, allowing the listener to focus on the intimate confession of the lyric. Then, the chorus hits, and the song explodes into a glorious, wall-of-sound orchestration. It’s cathartic, a moment of release that justifies the initial restraint. This is a song that shines when played on a quality setup, revealing the layers of sonic detail that were compressed out of existence on AM radio. For those of us investing in quality premium audio systems today, this recording offers a fascinating study in late-70s studio craft.
This level of studio sophistication didn’t come cheap, and it certainly didn’t come without creative tension. This was a band in flux, with personnel changes reflecting the internal struggle between maintaining their market identity and pursuing artistic credibility. It’s A Game was a defiant attempt to bridge that gap, a complex sound that asked fans to follow them from the gymnasium dance floor to the dimly lit amphitheater.
Imagine a young person in 1977, whose room walls were covered in tartan posters, spinning this album for the first time. The shock must have been palpable. This wasn’t the same band. This was the sound of a group trying to shed its skin, a painful but necessary evolution. It’s the sound of five men saying, “We are not kids anymore. Our music is not a fad; it’s a career.” The ambition encoded in the grooves of the vinyl is almost heartbreaking. The Rollers, for a moment, sounded like genuine contenders in the serious rock landscape.
“It’s a magnificent, desperate pivot—a piece of sophisticated pop that deserved a wider critical embrace than it received.”
The instrumental break is particularly noteworthy. A clean, effects-light guitar solo cuts through the strings and brass. It’s concise and melodic, avoiding the typical rock-god histrionics. Instead, it serves the song’s emotional arc, a moment of clear, expressive playing that grounds the track. Similarly, the careful overdubbing of backing vocals adds texture, turning the chorus into an anthemic moment.
It’s easy to dismiss the Bay City Rollers as a footnote in the history of teen-pop, but to do so is to miss the fascinating artistic gambles they made. It’s A Game, and its title track in particular, stands as a surprisingly mature document of that pivotal transition. It shows that even the most commercially-driven bands are capable of reaching for something deeper, something timeless. For anyone interested in the inner workings of pop metamorphosis, this is essential listening. The track’s complexity and depth invite a forensic analysis of its composition—perhaps it’s a song to recommend to anyone starting their piano lessons, for a masterclass in dynamic melodic arrangement. This track is a reminder that the most compelling musical stories are often found where popular appeal and genuine artistic striving collide. It deserves to be dusted off and reassessed not as a footnote in bubblegum history, but as a surprisingly lush and effective piece of AOR.
🎧 Listening Recommendations
-
Pilot – “Magic” (1974): Shares the same sparkling, mid-tempo AOR feel and lush, layered studio production, particularly in the harmonies.
-
10cc – “I’m Not in Love” (1975): Offers a similar sense of studio craft and orchestral sweep, using layered vocals and complex arrangements to create atmosphere.
-
Electric Light Orchestra (ELO) – “Telephone Line” (1976): Features the blend of piano-driven melody and dramatic, symphonic strings that “It’s A Game” clearly aimed for.
-
The Alan Parsons Project – “I Wouldn’t Want to Be Like You” (1977): Exemplifies the polished, professional, and slightly dramatic AOR sound that dominated the serious end of the rock market at the time.
-
Bread – “Make It With You” (1970): While earlier, it provides the template for the smooth, sophisticated guitar and piano accompaniment used in the Rollers’ more adult sound.