Earl Thomas Conley was one of country music’s most distinctive voices, blending traditional country storytelling with contemporary production elements. Among his many chart-topping hits, What I’d Say stands out as a heartfelt and evocative ballad that continues to resonate with fans decades after its release. The song, featured on his 1988 album The Heart of It All, encapsulates Conley’s signature smooth vocal delivery, poignant lyricism, and an expertly crafted instrumental arrangement.
In this review, we will explore the album that gave rise to this classic track, analyze the musical composition of What I’d Say, and provide listening recommendations for those who appreciate this style of country music. Additionally, we will touch on the instruments and production choices that make this piece of music a standout in Conley’s impressive discography.
The Heart of It All – A Landmark Album
Released in 1988, The Heart of It All was a defining album for Earl Thomas Conley, reaffirming his status as a dominant force in country music throughout the 1980s. This album produced several hit singles, but What I’d Say became one of the most memorable, reaching No. 1 on the Billboard Hot Country Songs chart.
The album’s title is a nod to Conley’s Ohio roots, and it is packed with themes of love, loss, and personal introspection. Each track showcases Conley’s ability to blend traditional country instrumentation with smooth, radio-friendly production. What I’d Say serves as a centerpiece, both emotionally and sonically, offering a melancholic yet relatable reflection on the pain of regret and longing.
The Instrumentation and Sounds of What I’d Say
One of the defining aspects of What I’d Say is its seamless blend of classic country instrumentation with a polished, contemporary sound. The song features a rich arrangement that includes:
- Electric and Acoustic Guitar: The delicate interplay between these guitars provides both rhythm and melodic depth. The lead guitar work in particular enhances the song’s emotional weight, delivering subtle but expressive licks that complement Conley’s vocals.
- Piano: A crucial element in the song’s arrangement, the piano adds warmth and resonance to the track, creating a sense of melancholy that aligns with the lyrical themes.
- Pedal Steel Guitar: This instrument, a staple of country music, is used sparingly but effectively in What I’d Say, reinforcing the song’s emotional pull and enhancing its depth.
- Soft Percussion: Rather than overpowering the composition, the drums provide a steady, gentle foundation, allowing the melody and lyrics to take center stage.
The production of What I’d Say is a perfect example of how Conley and his producers managed to craft songs that felt both traditional and modern. While the song remains deeply rooted in country music’s storytelling tradition, the polished production and instrumental choices allow it to transcend the genre’s conventional boundaries.
Lyrical Themes and Emotional Depth
Lyrically, What I’d Say is a poignant reflection on missed opportunities and the pain of love lost. The song’s narrator contemplates what he would say if given the chance to speak to a former lover again. The lyrics convey a deep sense of regret and unresolved emotions, making the song relatable to anyone who has ever looked back on a relationship with a sense of longing.
Conley’s delivery is key to the song’s impact. His voice carries a natural, conversational quality that makes the lyrics feel even more personal. Unlike the exaggerated twang often associated with traditional country music, Conley’s smooth, emotive vocal style allows the song to connect with a broad audience.
Why What I’d Say Stands Out
Many country songs explore themes of heartbreak and regret, but What I’d Say stands out due to its combination of lyrical simplicity and emotional weight. The song does not rely on grandiose metaphors or over-the-top storytelling. Instead, it paints a realistic and deeply human picture of love lost.
Additionally, the song’s production choices—particularly the balance between acoustic and electric instrumentation—help it maintain a timeless appeal. While some country hits from the late 1980s now feel dated due to heavy synthesizers or overproduced arrangements, What I’d Say remains fresh and relevant.
Similar Songs for Fans of What I’d Say
If you appreciate the heartfelt emotion and smooth production of What I’d Say, here are a few other songs you might enjoy:
- Keith Whitley – Don’t Close Your Eyes: Another classic from the same era, this song shares a similar theme of longing and regret.
- George Strait – The Chair: A masterclass in understated storytelling, this song mirrors Conley’s ability to convey deep emotion with subtlety.
- Vern Gosdin – Is It Raining at Your House: A hauntingly beautiful ballad that, like What I’d Say, explores themes of heartbreak and lost love.
- Alabama – Old Flame: Featuring rich instrumentation and emotional lyrics, this song offers a compelling listening experience for fans of Conley’s style.
The Lasting Impact of What I’d Say
Decades after its release, What I’d Say remains a staple in country music playlists and a fan favorite. Earl Thomas Conley’s ability to craft songs that are both deeply personal and universally relatable is evident in every line of this track.
The song’s instrumentation, particularly the interplay between guitar and piano, adds layers of emotion that elevate it beyond a simple ballad. For country music enthusiasts and casual listeners alike, What I’d Say serves as a timeless reminder of Conley’s talent and the power of well-crafted storytelling.
Whether you are revisiting this classic or discovering it for the first time, What I’d Say is a piece of music that continues to resonate with listeners, proving that great songs transcend time and trends. If you’re looking for an album that embodies the essence of 1980s country music, The Heart of It All is an essential listen.