The Ronettes, a quintessential girl group of the 1960s, left an indelible mark on the music industry with their heartfelt lyrics, lush instrumentation, and Phil Spector’s groundbreaking “Wall of Sound” production. One of their memorable tracks, “Is This What I Get For Loving You,” is a poignant and beautifully orchestrated piece of music that showcases the group’s vocal prowess and emotional depth. This blog delves into the essence of the song, its place within its album, and the masterful use of instruments like guitar and piano, which contribute to its enduring appeal.
The Album: A Snapshot of the Era
“Is This What I Get For Loving You” appears as part of the album The Ronettes Featuring Veronica, a collection that epitomizes the romantic yearning and heartbreak that defined the girl-group era. Released under Phil Spector’s Philles Records label, this album is a masterpiece of 1960s pop music, with each track meticulously crafted to resonate emotionally with the listener.
The album not only highlighted the vocal talents of Veronica Bennett (later known as Ronnie Spector) but also elevated The Ronettes into cultural icons. “Is This What I Get For Loving You” stands out for its raw emotion, blending sorrowful lyrics with a grandeur that underscores the themes of unrequited love and vulnerability.
Instruments and Sounds: The Heartbeat of the Song
Phil Spector’s “Wall of Sound” technique is the hallmark of this song. This production style layers multiple instruments to create a dense, symphonic sound that immerses the listener. The result is a lush and evocative atmosphere that perfectly complements the song’s emotional core.
Guitar
The guitar work in “Is This What I Get For Loving You” plays a subtle yet crucial role. The gentle strumming and melodic lines add texture to the arrangement, weaving through the orchestral backdrop without overpowering it. This understated approach allows the vocals to shine while enhancing the song’s melancholic mood.
Piano
The piano serves as an emotional anchor in the song, its cascading chords mirroring the ups and downs of the lyrics. The instrument adds a sense of intimacy and vulnerability, underscoring Ronnie Spector’s heart-wrenching delivery. In the bridge, the piano’s resonant tones elevate the track, making it a centerpiece of the arrangement.
Percussion and Strings
The percussion in the song is characteristic of Spector’s productions: a booming, echo-laden drumbeat that propels the track forward. Combined with sweeping string arrangements, the rhythm section creates a cinematic feel, as though the listener is being drawn into a larger-than-life love story.
Vocal Performance
Ronnie Spector’s vocals are the beating heart of “Is This What I Get For Loving You.” Her voice, tinged with vulnerability and longing, brings authenticity to the song’s themes of heartache and regret. The harmonies provided by the other Ronettes amplify the emotional intensity, making the song a powerful anthem of unfulfilled love.
Themes and Emotional Resonance
At its core, “Is This What I Get For Loving You” is a song about heartbreak and disillusionment. The lyrics reflect the universal pain of loving someone who doesn’t reciprocate those feelings. Lines like “I thought you’d be true to me / But now I can’t believe I was a fool” resonate deeply with anyone who has experienced the sting of betrayal.
The juxtaposition of grand orchestration with intimate, confessional lyrics is a hallmark of The Ronettes’ music. It allows the listener to connect with the song on both an emotional and sensory level, making it a timeless piece of music.
The Legacy of “Is This What I Get For Loving You”
While it may not have achieved the commercial success of The Ronettes’ iconic hit “Be My Baby,” this song remains a fan favorite for its raw emotion and intricate production. It exemplifies the artistry of 1960s pop music, where every element—from the lyrics to the arrangement—was crafted with meticulous care.
The song also highlights Phil Spector’s genius as a producer, demonstrating his ability to bring out the best in his artists. His “Wall of Sound” production has influenced countless musicians, making tracks like this one foundational pieces of pop music history.
Listening Recommendations: Songs with a Similar Vibe
If you love “Is This What I Get For Loving You,” here are a few other songs that capture a similar emotional and sonic landscape:
- “Be My Baby” by The Ronettes
A quintessential track from the same group, this song features the same lush orchestration and heartfelt lyrics. - “Will You Love Me Tomorrow” by The Shirelles
Another classic girl-group anthem, this song explores the uncertainty of love with poignant lyrics and soulful harmonies. - “Then He Kissed Me” by The Crystals
Produced by Phil Spector, this track shares the grandiose production style and romantic themes of The Ronettes’ music. - “You’ve Lost That Lovin’ Feelin’” by The Righteous Brothers
A timeless ballad featuring Spector’s signature production and a similar emotional intensity. - “Where Did Our Love Go” by The Supremes
This Motown classic pairs infectious melodies with lyrics about heartbreak, making it a perfect companion to The Ronettes’ work.
Conclusion
“Is This What I Get For Loving You” is a testament to The Ronettes’ enduring appeal and the brilliance of Phil Spector’s production. Its masterful blend of guitar, piano, strings, and emotive vocals creates a rich tapestry of sound that continues to captivate listeners decades later. Whether you’re a fan of 1960s music or simply appreciate well-crafted songs about love and loss, this track is a must-listen.
The song reminds us of the power of music to evoke deep emotions and connect us to shared experiences. For anyone exploring the golden era of pop music, this piece of music is a shining example of why The Ronettes remain legends in the industry.
Video
Lyrics
There’s been a lot of talk around
That you’ve been seen with a certain party
And now I’m so afraid I’m losing you
Oh baby, don’t tell me you don’t want my love
I couldn’t give it to just anybody
Baby, won’t you tell me it’s not true?
Don’t leave me baby
Don’t tell me it’s over
After I trusted you
And did my best to make you happy
Is this what I get for loving you, baby? (Oh, is this what I get)
Is this what I get for loving you, baby?
There was a night when you held me tight
And you said you’d always love me (you said you’d always love me)
You said you’d never hurt me (you said you’d never hurt me)
What would there be left for me
It’s such a cruel world to be alone in
I always needed you to look out for me
And baby, I’m gonna miss your loving arms
They’re the only arms I feel at home in
Don’t you know how lonely I’m gonna be
Don’t leave me baby
Don’t tell me it’s over
After I trusted you and did my best to make you happy
Is this what I get for loving you, baby? (Oh, is this what I get)
Is this what I get for loving you, baby?
There was a night when you held me tight
And you said you’d always love me (you said you’d always love me)
You said you’d never hurt me (you said you’d never hurt me)
Don’t leave me baby
Is this what I get for loving you, baby? (Is this what I get)
Is this what I get for loving you, baby?
There was a night when you held me tight
And you said you’d always love me (you said you’d always love me)
You said you’d never hurt me (you said you’d never hurt me)
You know I love you, baby