The American folk music scene has produced countless gems, but few artists have embodied the genre’s heartfelt sincerity and narrative depth quite like Peter, Paul & Mary. With their intricate harmonies and socially conscious themes, the trio shaped the folk revival of the 1960s. One standout piece of music from their illustrious career is “A’ Soalin’,” a haunting and evocative song that captures the essence of folk tradition and storytelling.
Featured on their 1963 album Moving, “A’ Soalin’” serves as a masterclass in blending historical roots with modern musical sensibilities. This review delves into the song’s rich cultural tapestry, its instrumentation, and its lasting impact, while also offering listening recommendations for fans seeking similar experiences.
The Album: Moving
Peter, Paul & Mary’s Moving album is a cornerstone of their discography, showcasing their signature mix of earnest social commentary and reimagined traditional songs. Released during a pivotal time in American history, the album combines the trio’s characteristic three-part harmonies with a careful curation of material that resonates deeply with listeners.
“A’ Soalin’” is nestled among tracks like “Puff, the Magic Dragon” and “Settle Down (Goin’ Down That Highway),” reflecting the group’s ability to shift seamlessly between whimsical storytelling and poignant calls to action. While Moving as a whole reflects the turbulence and idealism of the 1960s, “A’ Soalin’” stands out as an ode to a deeper historical past, drawing inspiration from medieval English traditions.
A Journey Through “A’ Soalin’”
“A’ Soalin’” is a reinterpretation of the traditional English folk song “Soul Cake,” a tune associated with the medieval custom of “souling.” During Allhallowtide, poor individuals would go door-to-door singing and offering prayers for the dead in exchange for soul cakes, small baked goods symbolizing blessings. Peter, Paul & Mary’s version expands on this historical context, weaving an evocative musical narrative that transcends its origins.
The Instrumentation
The arrangement of “A’ Soalin’” is as captivating as its lyrics, drawing listeners into its otherworldly atmosphere. The song opens with soft, lilting guitar notes, a hallmark of the folk genre, setting a pensive tone. As the harmonies build, additional elements such as the tambourine and subtle percussion provide texture without overpowering the vocal performance. The acoustic guitar remains central throughout, offering a rhythmic and melodic anchor.
Interestingly, while the trio primarily focuses on the guitar and voice in this track, the haunting quality of the song suggests the presence of more ephemeral sounds, like wind instruments or choral echoes. This is not an actual feature of the piece but rather a testament to how skillfully their harmonies evoke layers of emotion and depth. While the song does not explicitly feature instruments like the piano, its fluid pacing and tonal shifts evoke the measured grace often associated with classical music piano compositions.
The Vocal Performance
Vocally, Peter, Paul & Mary shine on “A’ Soalin’.” Their harmonies are a perfect balance of plaintive yearning and reverent solemnity, with each member taking turns to emphasize particular verses and phrases. The trio’s ability to blend their voices while maintaining a distinct emotional arc is unparalleled, creating a listening experience that feels both intimate and profound.
The refrain, “A soul! A soul! A soul cake! Please, good missus, a soul cake,” is a recurring plea that echoes the song’s roots in communal charity and spiritual reflection. Each repetition carries a subtle shift in tone, capturing a mix of hope, humility, and tradition.
Themes and Cultural Significance
“A’ Soalin’” is more than just a song; it’s a narrative steeped in history and spirituality. Its themes of community, mortality, and generosity resonate universally, making it as relevant today as when it was first performed. By reinterpreting an ancient folk custom for contemporary audiences, Peter, Paul & Mary remind us of the enduring power of music to connect us to our shared human heritage.
Moreover, the song’s structure, which alternates between historical storytelling and universal messages, mirrors the best traditions of folk music. This interplay ensures that “A’ Soalin’” is not simply a nostalgic look at the past but a living piece of music that continues to inspire.
High-Quality Listening Recommendations
For those enchanted by the spellbinding atmosphere of “A’ Soalin’,” there are several other songs and artists worth exploring. Below are a few recommendations that echo the themes, instrumentation, and emotional depth found in Peter, Paul & Mary’s work:
- Simon & Garfunkel – “Scarborough Fair/Canticle” Like “A’ Soalin’,” this track reimagines a traditional English ballad. Its delicate arrangement and lush harmonies create a similarly haunting and reflective mood.
- Joan Baez – “Barbara Allen” A traditional folk ballad interpreted by another luminary of the 1960s folk revival, “Barbara Allen” offers a poignant narrative and a pared-down acoustic style reminiscent of Peter, Paul & Mary’s arrangements.
- The Seekers – “I’ll Never Find Another You” This song showcases the harmony-driven approach characteristic of 1960s folk-pop, providing an accessible and uplifting counterpoint to the solemnity of “A’ Soalin’.”
- Fairport Convention – “Matty Groves” For listeners intrigued by the historical and folkloric elements of “A’ Soalin’,” this British folk-rock classic delves into another tragic and evocative tale from the past.
- Celtic Woman – “Dúlamán” With its roots in Irish folk music, “Dúlamán” captures a similar spirit of tradition and ethereal beauty, complemented by contemporary arrangements.
Conclusion: The Enduring Power of Tradition
“A’ Soalin’” is a testament to Peter, Paul & Mary’s ability to reimagine tradition while making it resonate with modern audiences. Its rich instrumentation, impeccable vocal harmonies, and profound historical roots combine to create a song that feels timeless and transformative. As a part of the Moving album, it stands out not only as a highlight but as a piece of music that underscores the trio’s contribution to the folk canon.
In today’s fast-paced world, revisiting songs like “A’ Soalin’” offers a moment of introspection and connection to the past. It’s a reminder of the simple yet profound power of community, storytelling, and music—a legacy that Peter, Paul & Mary have left for generations to come.
For fans of acoustic guitar-driven songs with layered harmonies, or those seeking a deeper appreciation of folk traditions, “A’ Soalin’” is an essential listen. Whether paired with other tracks from Moving or explored alongside similar artists, this song remains a hauntingly beautiful celebration of the human spirit.