The late 1970s. The air was thick with the scent of vinyl and the promise of a sound that could bridge the chasm between Nashville’s honky-tonk past and the soaring, string-laden future of adult contemporary pop. On the radio dial, the signals bled into one another—a country ballad might feature the very same lush production as a Top 40 heartbreak anthem. At the center of this gorgeous, commercially potent convergence stood Ronnie Milsap, a virtuoso blind pianist with a voice capable of both immense power and the most delicate vulnerability.
Milsap had already established himself as a force, bridging the gap from soul-tinged R&B covers to sophisticated countrypolitan hits. But 1977 brought what many consider his quintessential statement: the album It Was Almost Like a Song. The title track, a breathtaking meditation on a love that achieved near-perfection before fracturing, wasn’t just another hit; it was a manifesto for Milsap’s ambition, a declaration that country music could be every bit as orchestral and emotionally expansive as the best of pop.
The song was a collaboration built for grandeur. Produced by Tom Collins and arranged by Bill Justis, it showcases a meticulous attention to sound design, proving that the sonic backdrop is as crucial as the vocal performance. Collins, a key figure in Milsap’s RCA run, understood how to position the singer’s rich, agile tenor against a backdrop that felt simultaneously intimate and cinematic.
The opening moments set the stage with immediate gravity. There is no gentle fade-in; the song begins, mid-thought, with Milsap’s voice supported by the unmistakable signature of his own instrument. The piano anchors the entire piece of music, not with simple chords, but with arpeggiated figures that weave through the verses like a comforting, yet melancholic, presence. It is a masterclass in restrained virtuosity, never showy, always serving the lyric.
As Milsap introduces the central metaphor—the memory of love as a melody that almost became a symphony—the arrangement blossoms. This is where the song truly defines the “crossover” era. The rhythm section is solid but subtle, providing a gentle forward momentum that keeps the ballad from stalling. Crucially, it’s the sweeping string arrangement that transforms the recording from a good country song into a piece of enduring premium audio. They enter with dramatic swells, a silken counter-melody that seems to weep alongside Milsap’s vocal line.
The strings are not merely ornamentation. They are a character in the narrative, representing the expansive, perfect world the lovers built. They swell precisely at the points where the emotional weight is heaviest, providing a harmonic uplift that suggests the sheer scale of the love that was lost. There’s a particular, glistening quality to the high strings, a touch of reverb that suggests a vast, empty hall—the space where the beautiful music once played.
Contrast is key to the song’s success. Against the immense soundscape created by the orchestra, the acoustic guitar provides moments of grounded simplicity. It is often tucked back in the mix, a gentle, strummed texture that recalls the track’s country roots, a nod to the simple, honest sentiment at the core of the heartbreak. This juxtaposition—orchestral sweep against acoustic intimacy—gives the listener a tangible sense of both the glamour and the grit of the memory.
Imagine a listener in 1977, perhaps driving a long stretch of interstate, the radio tuned just right. Milsap’s voice cuts through the static, a beacon of refined emotion. He sings about the moments before the fall: “The way you looked / The way you smiled / A chapter from a story book.” His phrasing is impeccable, stretching the vowels of key words just enough to let the emotion breathe. He doesn’t rush the lines; he savors the memory before having to acknowledge the brutal reality of the ending.
“The song is a masterclass in controlled devastation, where the instrumental richness only serves to amplify the raw vulnerability of the human voice.”
The performance is a clinic in emotional restraint. Milsap never pushes his voice into a strained belt; the power comes from the depth of his resonance. Even when he reaches the chorus—the title line—it is delivered with a kind of resigned ache. It’s not an angry realization, but a painful, quiet acceptance. It’s a moment that resonates profoundly with anyone who has ever mourned the loss of a near-perfect connection.
The required complexity of the track’s arrangement means that a great deal of effort went into its dissemination. Many aspiring musicians in the late 70s, captivated by the song’s sophisticated harmonic movement, would have sought out the sheet music to study the interplay between the bass line, the string pads, and the piano chords. The composition, written by Archie Jordan and Kye Fleming, is structurally sound, building to a thrilling, cathartic crescendo before gently dissolving back into silence.
The ultimate appeal of this song is its ability to elevate the intensely personal into the universally grand. It’s a reminder that a broken heart doesn’t just feel like a small ache; it feels like the sudden silence after a massive, beautiful sound. It is a heartbreak that requires an entire orchestra to describe its scale. Ronnie Milsap, through his signature artistry, gave the era a perfect encapsulation of that feeling. It remains, nearly five decades later, a towering achievement in the country-pop canon, a song that defined an era of emotional openness on the airwaves. This track, more than many others from that time, makes a compelling case for a dedicated re-listen through the best available speakers or studio headphones to catch every detail of Justis’s marvelous arrangement.
Listening Recommendations
-
Charley Pride – “Kiss an Angel Good Mornin’” (1971): Shares the same RCA-era countrypolitan polish and lush, slightly reserved vocal delivery.
-
Kenny Rogers – “She Believes In Me” (1979): Another sophisticated, piano-driven ballad built on a similar foundation of pop-crossover arrangement and intimate, narrative lyricism.
-
Glen Campbell – “Wichita Lineman” (1968): Features Jimmy Webb’s masterful orchestral arrangement, showcasing a similar blend of folk simplicity and classical complexity.
-
Conway Twitty – “I’d Love to Lay You Down” (1980): A later example that carries the torch for the slow-burning, emotionally direct country ballad with rich production value.
-
Dolly Parton – “Here You Come Again” (1977): Released the same year, this song also represents the Nashville sound’s shift toward accessible, smooth pop production.
-
Eddie Rabbitt – “You Don’t Come Home To Me Anymore” (1976): Features the same production ethos (Tom Collins) and Milsap-esque keyboard-focused sonic blueprint.