Released in 1967, “I Second That Emotion” by Smokey Robinson & The Miracles is one of Motown’s enduring hits, blending catchy melody, relatable lyrics, and a smooth vocal performance that’s captured the hearts of listeners for decades. As a classic piece of the Motown era, the song is a gem that showcases the exceptional talent of Smokey Robinson and his group, The Miracles, along with the songwriting and production prowess of the Motown label. The song’s legacy is not only in its commercial success but also in its impact on pop and soul music and its capacity to remain relevant across generations. Here’s a deeper dive into what makes “I Second That Emotion” such an iconic song.
The Origins of “I Second That Emotion”
The inspiration behind “I Second That Emotion” reportedly came from a simple verbal slip. Co-writer Al Cleveland was shopping with Smokey Robinson and commented on a purchase by saying, “I second that emotion” instead of the common phrase, “I second that motion.” The playful slip inspired Robinson to suggest they write a song around this unique turn of phrase. As one of Motown’s principal writers, Smokey Robinson was known for his ability to transform everyday situations and clever wordplay into profound musical expressions. Thus, “I Second That Emotion” was born, combining Robinson’s lyrical genius with a relatable theme of love and vulnerability.
The Theme and Lyrics
The lyrics of “I Second That Emotion” explore a central theme in many of Robinson’s songs: love, trust, and emotional openness. The song’s protagonist expresses a cautious approach to love, suggesting that he can’t simply return affection based on words alone—there needs to be sincerity and action behind the emotions expressed. The line, “If you feel like giving me a lifetime of devotion, I second that emotion,” encapsulates the sentiment of seeking a love that is genuine and lasting rather than fleeting or superficial.
Robinson’s lyrics capture this tension beautifully, balancing vulnerability and self-assurance. The phrase “I second that emotion” serves as both a clever play on words and a powerful message of mutual trust and reciprocation in relationships. The emotional honesty in the lyrics makes the song relatable to anyone who has ever experienced the desire for a love that feels both real and reciprocated.
Smokey Robinson’s Vocal Delivery
Smokey Robinson’s voice is central to the magic of “I Second That Emotion.” His distinctive falsetto is both gentle and expressive, conveying a sense of vulnerability that perfectly matches the song’s theme. Robinson’s voice has always had a unique ability to convey complex emotions with apparent ease, making listeners feel as though he’s speaking directly to them. In “I Second That Emotion,” his vocal delivery is smooth yet emotive, bringing out the depth in lyrics that might otherwise seem simple.
In the song, Robinson’s voice blends seamlessly with the harmonies of The Miracles, creating a rich vocal texture that complements the instrumental arrangement. The call-and-response structure, a staple in many Motown songs, adds another layer of interaction, making the song feel like an intimate conversation. This conversational style of singing helped the song resonate deeply with audiences, adding to its appeal and longevity.
The Production and Instrumentation
One of the hallmarks of Motown music is the exceptional quality of its production, and “I Second That Emotion” is no exception. The song was produced by Smokey Robinson himself alongside Al Cleveland, with Motown’s legendary in-house band, The Funk Brothers, providing the instrumentation. The rhythm section is both tight and groovy, with a smooth bassline that underpins the entire track, creating a sense of movement that keeps listeners engaged.
The arrangement is a brilliant example of the Motown “wall of sound” approach, with layered instrumentation that includes piano, strings, and subtle horns, all mixed in a way that enhances Robinson’s vocals without overwhelming them. The interplay between these elements creates a rich sonic landscape that invites listeners to lose themselves in the music. The steady rhythm and catchy melody make the song danceable and accessible, while the intricate instrumentation rewards repeat listens.
Cultural Impact and Legacy
“I Second That Emotion” achieved significant commercial success, reaching number 4 on the Billboard Hot 100 and number 1 on the R&B chart. Its success cemented The Miracles’ status as one of Motown’s premier groups and helped solidify Smokey Robinson’s reputation as one of the most talented songwriters and performers of the era.
Beyond its chart success, “I Second That Emotion” has left a lasting legacy in pop culture. The song has been covered by numerous artists, including Diana Ross & the Supremes with The Temptations, Jerry Garcia, and Japan, demonstrating its wide appeal across genres and generations. Each cover brings a unique interpretation to the song, proving its adaptability and timelessness. The phrase “I second that emotion” has also entered popular vocabulary, further embedding the song in cultural consciousness.
Why the Song Still Resonates Today
Decades after its release, “I Second That Emotion” continues to resonate because of its universal theme and relatable lyrics. In a world where relationships are often complicated and fleeting, the song’s message about sincerity and reciprocated love feels timeless. Smokey Robinson’s skillful lyrics capture the complexities of human relationships in a way that still feels fresh and relevant, even in a vastly different social landscape.
Additionally, the song’s catchy melody, polished production, and emotional honesty have ensured its place as a classic in the American music canon. For many listeners, “I Second That Emotion” is more than just a song from the past; it’s a reminder of Motown’s golden age and the timeless appeal of authentic, heartfelt music. The song serves as a testament to Robinson’s genius as a songwriter and performer, as well as to Motown’s commitment to producing music that resonates on a deeply human level.
Conclusion
“I Second That Emotion” by Smokey Robinson & The Miracles is more than just a hit song from the 1960s; it’s a piece of musical history that has continued to captivate listeners for generations. With its clever lyrics, soulful vocals, and polished production, the song embodies the best of Motown and remains an enduring reminder of Smokey Robinson’s unparalleled talent. Today, as new listeners discover the song and longtime fans revisit it, “I Second That Emotion” continues to evoke the same feelings of connection, love, and nostalgia, proving its timelessness and its place in the pantheon of great American music.